I've been struggling against shit that chafes against my very being since I was a small child.
Today, there was a post on Tenkar's Tavern about +Frank Mentzer getting booted from the Dragonfoot forum. You can read about it here.
My assessment? Ideally, we would live in a meritocracy where the merits of creative effort would outweigh all other considerations. That means artists, writers, musicians, filmmakers, etc. would essentially be running the world. That might sound insane to some, but oh well. I've been called a madman many times over.
A popular RPG reviewer, Endzeitgeist, has been taking my titles to task for over a year. I not only submit to it, but keep sending him PDFs to pick over like the masochist I appear to be.
It's not just a love of pain, though. Often, feedback helps improve the work. Normally, I'm grateful for his critique, even though his particular feedback rarely helps (we have differing design goals). But I really can't beat the signal boost he provides. However, today's rpg.net review of Adventure Writing Like A Fucking Boss was simply too much for me to bear.
I've copy/pasted it here for posterity (here is the forum thread - with a response from Endzeitgeist - which I've also replied to)...
First, I'd like to get this out of the way - Adventure Writing Like A Fucking Boss is also a primer for those looking to self-publish their scenarios. Gamers love to share their work (and occasionally get paid for it). This guide will help such enterprising adventure writers. Is this the only book they need in the world to succeed in their goal? Probably not, but I see published scenario after scenario after scenario that fails to live up to the baseline standards we should all strive for.
My book serves a definite purpose. It's needed. Hundreds of scenarios a year would be improved by adhering to my advice. Just because it leaves out things that might benefit those looking to get published by Pathfinder... I don't take that as a knock against my book. If anything, Adventure Writing Like a Fucking Boss is a manifesto against that kind of RPG corporatization. The revolution starts now!
Now, onto my primary grievance...
I have to object to the "wasted my money" part of your review's number system (4/1), Endzeitgeist.
Sure, if told about the basics of adventure writing, you might say "Yeah, I know all that." However, that doesn't mean the material is totally redundant or useless or obvious to everyone but noobs. Having everything in one place is valuable. So is the material's presentation (examples, illustrations, way things are communicated, personal insight, and motivation).
Additionally, things that are important to you and your gaming style are not a priority for me. For instance, a PDF filled with intricate Pathfinder-esque rules about spells having to do with wheat fields or feats related to a bard/shaman/canteen-boy would have no value to me (other than possible amusement/ridicule), though you might favor them with 5 stars. That's almost inconceivable to me, but you can't argue about taste. On the other hand, a guidebook about adventure writing is more or less universally valuable to gamers - GMs especially. If any of the advice (regardless of whether the information was previously known to the reviewer) has merit, then I can't understand a "1" rating.
Anyone plunking down $3, checking to see the page-count of 14, or reading the product's description should not be surprised that Adventure Writing Like A Fucking Boss is not an exhaustive treatise on every aspect of writing, designing, and self-publishing RPG adventures. So, I'm not clear on why this title is being penalized for having a limited scope.
Your review of Play Your Character Like A Fucking Boss received higher marks in both categories, even though the titles are similar (though one is a guide for players and the other is a guide for writing adventures).
And what about this line at the review's conclusion? 4 and 1 averaged together makes 2.5, unless my math is ever worse than I thought.
[QUOTE]In the end, my final verdict will clock in at 3.5 stars[/QUOTE]
Our stylistic, aesthetic, and philosophical differences keep us from seeing eye to eye on many things, Endzeitgeist, but I just don't understand what happened here.
While I'm not part of the establishment, I also get short-changed by the flamboyant, self-aggrandizing RPG counter-culture that either ignores me, blatantly tries to tear my work down, or minimizes my contributions.
That's ok. I have the third side. Neither the empire nor rebellion (though if I had to pick a side, it would obviously be the rebels), but a man on his own - yeah, I'm the Boba Fett of the RPG universe.
Just as in my youth, I'm still struggling. Down with RPG corporatization! Hail the OSR! Long live the revolution!
Thanks to all those who've been supporting, encouraging, and contributing to The Work.
Venger As'Nas Satanis
High Priest of Kort'thalis Publishing