Friday, November 3, 2023

Divine Fallacy [random table]

 

As the video shows [the video], I've decided to make a random table that better replicates actual creation.  When human beings attempt to play God, it usually goes awry.

We tend to think of things logically and from a top-down perspective.  What's the shortest route between two points?  But human beings, emblematic of creation, doesn't work like that.  We are not machines to be programed, hacked, and placed within the greater whole, nor are we beasts of flesh driven by desire, chemical reactions, and hormones.  

Not only would this go great with my eldritch, gonzo, science-fantasy, post-apocalypse, humor, sleaze, pop-culture, and grindhouse exploitation campaign setting CHA'ALT, but similar RPGs and settings.

Roll on the following table to determine just how things have gone pear-shaped...


Substitute Gods

  1. Bureaucracy!  Whatever it is needs an extra layer of complication to circumvent.  
  2. As it stands, the thing lacks a true connection to the divine.  It's missing God.
  3. Too religious; it's just overly preachy or self-flagellating or superstitious.
  4. Byzantine to the point where obscurity and labyrinthine misdirection become the point.
  5. Humanoids are not islands, we are social creatures, as well.  It lacks any sense of community.
  6. It's driven by social contagion.  Rather than performing its primary function, it has become merely a social outlet.
  7. This thing fails to account for self-sabotage.  It's become an exercise in repeatedly kicking oneself in the nuts.
  8. Three steps forward, one step back.  Constant progress is impossible.  If things are always "getting better" that usually means that somewhere, somehow things (big, important things) are actually getting worse.
  9. Self-loathing.  It's easy to forget that we are sometimes our own worst enemy.  Most people fail to see that we hate ourselves and it shows.
  10.  The Gods secretly hate us.  They never grant a benefit without taking something else away from us.
  11. Everything comes down to sex.  If it can be used to fuel our lust and degeneracy, it will be.
  12. Nature curves - eventually, ideas, concepts, and principles in favor of "A" will, one day, be ferociously against "A."
  13. People are motivated by fear - whatever they're most afraid of will soon become their master.
  14. High levels of intelligence and wisdom are rare.  It's more likely that a calculation error was made at the very beginning... making the entire thing erroneous. 
  15. Betrayal!  Just as Jesus had Judas and Caesar had Brutus, so too will someone towards the top come along and betray the group or just the leader.  Either way, one person's actions will be the thing's undoing.
  16. Progress moves too quickly creating a slippery slope... what seemed impossible at the beginning is now all too real.
  17. It goes too far - the initial concept was good, but it managed to throw the baby out with the bathwater.
  18. The old ways are best - but not always!  Sometimes, actual progress is at hand, yet conventional wisdom and/or conservative values simply get in the way.
  19. Humanoids like to put their faith in false Gods; the idols of high-tech, science, artificial intelligence, or anything that tries to prove something one way or the other turns out to also be a bad idea more often than not.
  20. Roll twice!

Well, there you have it, folks.  A random table that both replicates the divine and human attempts to mirror the divine.  Basically, it's a miracle the human race has survived at all.

Thanks for reading,

VS


7 comments:

  1. Hm. I can't make heads or tails of this. Is it a critique of whatever "religion" the PCs profess to follow in-game? A comment on real-world "religions"? I can't see an applicable use in-game or out.
    When I read stuff like this I worry, because it reminds me of that time Dave Sim had a "religious" experience and flew up his own spiritual ass, leaving the rest of his run on his masterpiece comic work Cerebus as interesting and coherent as corned beef hash.
    I wouldn't wish that on a Trump, so I hope it's just me who's to much of an atheist to "get it"...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Lucien, what's up?

      Your comment strikes me as a little bizarre. If anything, this random table is a scathing critique of religion, while I myself have always felt a strong connection with God.

      But let's get to the point of this random table. I had hoped it could determine the pitfalls, shortcomings, and bad luck for any number of humanoid-based endeavors. For instance...

      A group of humanoids start a new religion [I rolled a 3... their religion is simply too religious; all fluff, no meat and potatoes], vile cultists engineer a method to genocide non-believers in their city [I rolled a 1... instead of being straightforward, their genocidal plans require a final solution ritual which can only be performed by the High Priest while he's getting a blowjob from multiple Sisters of the Blessed Sacrilege simultaneously as the ha'avarti moon is ascendant], a cabal within the royal court see the Duke as unfit to rule and make plans to "dethrone" him [I rolled an 8... while their plan to remove the Duke is working, it's putting the realm in even greater jeopardy than before as neighboring forces now see their ruler as weak], or a dramatic troupe of actors rehearse a new play that reveres The King In Yellow [I rolled a 19... the majority of actors are secret worshipers of Ha'astur, and hope their play will convert audience members into His Yellow Depravity].

      What unexpected wrinkle or obstacle rears its ugly head as people go about their business? Roll on this random table to find out. You know, that kind of thing. ;)

      Delete
  2. Okay, I think I get it! I guess "religion" always gets me a little jittery. A table to determine how this particular "religion" has gone wrong. Seems pretty straight-forward when you look at it this way. Thanks for the clarification!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No prob, hoss. Did you watch the accompanying video? While it isn't necessary, it'll provide useful context.

      Delete
  3. Yeah, no, sorry. I have a thing about watching videos. I know it sounds bizarre. I sound bizarre. It's a neurodivergent thing, pretty sure. Being bugged by an entire medium isn't normal, I'm aware of that. Sorry.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I understand. Different things bother different people.

      Delete
    2. I may or may not be neurodivergent, but my son is. I know I can't watch 90+ minute game session streaming unless the people are playing normally and having fun. And if they announce pronouns right out of the gate (did I need a He/Him for the guy with a Smith Brothers beard?) or announce their sexuality at the intro and through the course of it, I recoil like a vampire shown the cross.
      I also can't stand the sound of a broom sweeping concrete or similar pavement. It's like nails on a chalkboard. I also want to stab people with a fork if they stick their tongue out like a lizard before taking a bite of food. But thats just me.🤷🏻‍♂️
      We all have our likes, dislikes and aversions. You are you. Just think how many YouTube ads you've avoided! Thats commendable.

      Delete